Efficiency vs. Effectiveness

This is a blog about Effective Software Design, so it is important to first make clear what do we mean by “effective”.

Peter Drucker defined the difference between being efficient and being effective:

• Efficiency is the capacity to do things right.
• Effectiveness is the capacity to do the right thing.

A manual worker is expected to be efficient. He must perform his task following the orders he was given by his superiors. His work is judged in terms of the quantity and quality of items he is able to produce in some unit of time. The manual worker must do things right.

A knowledge worker is expected to be effective. His work includes making decisions, and therefore he cannot be directly instructed by others about how to perform his task. He produces knowledge, ideas and information that must then be applied to become products. The knowledge worker must do the right thing.

In the past, programmers were more like manual workers. The programming languages were very simple, with just a few elementary constructs. The programmer’s task was to assemble instructions in order to obtain the desired effect. Programmers had to be efficient, and the efficiency of the programmer could be measured by the number of lines of code (LOC) that he could produce in some unit of time.

Today, with the advent of object-oriented programming languages, the nature of programming tasks has changed. For any possible problem being resolved there are certainly libraries of classes that can be easily reused. For many complex systems there are frameworks that already provide most of the required functionality, and that need only be extended with a relatively small development effort.

In this new reality, measuring the LOC produced by the programmer is most likely the wrong thing. Because if he is writing too much, he is probably reusing too few. It is common to see less experienced programmers constantly “reinventing the wheel”, creating again classes that are ready to use in some library. As Peter Drucker said:

“There is nothing so useless as doing efficiently that which should not be done at all.”

Therefore, programmers today should be expected to be effective. They should know about the available frameworks and class libraries, and their work should consist mainly in deciding how to extend and reuse them. These decisions are design decisions, and the effective programmer must be able to compare design alternatives and select “the right one”.

For example, Design Patterns can be described as effective software design decisions for several abstract problems that were exhaustively studied and classified.

I hope the articles in this blog will help you develop your skills and make you more effective as a software designer, so that you will be able to “do the right thing”.

About Hayim Makabee

Veteran software developer, enthusiastic programmer, author of a book on Object-Oriented Programming, co-founder and CEO at KashKlik, an innovative Influencer Marketing platform.
This entry was posted in Efficacy and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to Efficiency vs. Effectiveness

  1. Raanan Avargil says:

    I would say: “do the right thing right”
    Interesting blog.


    Raanan

  2. pandastudent says:

    Simplicity…the code that is not written. I will be reading. 🙂

    Ann

  3. Hayim,

    I have just known your blog and liked it so much I have decided to start reading all your posts from the beginning.

    Doubt: Do you have some book with all (or the most important) posts of this blog? If the answer is no, what do you think about it?

    Congratulations for your work!

    Saulo

  4. Pingback: Efficiency and Effectiveness in Software Development Teams - Coding with Empathy

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s