The Etrog, Idealism and Concrete Choices

etrogIn the holiday of Succot, Jews make a blessing over the Four Species, including a special fruit called the Etrog. The Etrog is similar to a lemon, but it has a different shape and delicious smell. In the past the Etrog was considered a rare fruit, and it could be very expensive. When observant Jews chose an Etrog for the blessing, they looked for a beautiful one, which is called an “Etrog Mehoudar”.

There is an old tale about an Etrog dealer who arrives in a small village in Eastern Europe. The habitants of this village wanted to buy beautiful Etrogs to say the blessing, but they were not sure about how to choose a good one. So they would ask the Etrog dealer to give them a beautiful Etrog, and then go ask the Rav if it is really a good one.

When they arrived in the Rav’s house with the Etrog, they would ask:

“Rav, is this Etrog beautiful? Is it Mehoudar?”

Then the Rav would examine carefully the Etrog and answer:

“I’m sorry, but this Etrog is not Mehoudar.”

Then the person would return the Etrog to the dealer, claiming that the Rav said it was not Mehoudar.

After this happened several times, the dealer understood that he would not be able to sell any of his Etrogs, and then he decided to talk to the Rav. He went to his house and said:

“Rav, you must help me, no one wants to buy my Etrogs.”

The Rav answered:

“I’m sorry, but if they ask me if the Etrog is Mehoudar, I must say the truth.”

Then the dealer insisted:

“But Rav, if no one buys my Etrogs I will lose everything, and no one will have an Etrog to say the blessing.”

The Rav analyzed the situation and then proposed:

“Instead of giving a single Etrog to each person, you will give two Etrogs. Then, when they come to me, they will ask: ‘Which one among these two Etrogs is the most Mehoudar?’ And in this case I will always have a positive answer.”

Idealism and Concrete Choices

The Etrog Mehoudar represents our ideals. It is a symbol of perfection, of the satisfaction of all our desires. It is extremely important to have ideals, but we must always remember that we are constrained by the concrete choices we have at a particular moment.

It is important to have an Etrog Mehoudar, but when the holiday of Succot starts it is more important to have some Etrog to say the blessing, any Etrog, even if this Etrog is not Mehoudar.

As in the quote: “A goal is a dream with a deadline.” – Napoleon Hill

If the Etrog Mehoudar is the dream, then the beginning of Succot is the deadline. The goal is to have some Etrog to be able to say the blessing.

In the solution proposed by the Rav, the two Etrogs offered by the dealer are the unique concrete choices. The two choices are a limitation, but also part of the solution.

At any specific point in time, we must be wise to understand what our concrete choices are, and then select the best one based on our ideals.

Idealism and Software Development

Software developers are proud of the products they create, and they always want them to be as good as possible. A good piece of software should have many quality attributes: It should be well designed, should be efficient, and should not have bugs. But in our quest of the perfect software, it is easy to miss the deadlines.

One symptom of excessive perfectionism in software development is Analysis Paralysis: “The state of over-analyzing (or over-thinking) a situation so that a decision or action is never taken, in effect paralyzing the outcome.” In this case, software developers may spend too much time writing documents and drawing diagrams instead of writing code.

Another symptom is Featuritis: “The ongoing expansion or addition of new features in a product.” In this case the product will never be ready, because there will always be a new feature which may be added to make it better. Just another feature to make it perfect…

A solution to avoid these mistakes is to focus on a product that is both small and has very concrete purposes. This is the idea behind the concept of Minimum Viable Product, proposed by Eric Ries in his book “The Lean Startup”.

In summary:

There is no contradiction between idealism and pragmatism, as long as:

  • We are able to identify our concrete choices.
  • We use our ideals to select the best choice.

If you celebrate Succot, I wish you a Chag Sameach!

About Hayim Makabee

Veteran software developer, enthusiastic programmer, author of a book on Object-Oriented Programming, co-founder and CEO at KashKlik, an innovative Influencer Marketing platform.
This entry was posted in Efficacy, Jewish Sources and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

8 Responses to The Etrog, Idealism and Concrete Choices

  1. Lily says:

    the pursue of perfection is a difficult task..but the way you presented with the ETROG solution you made it simple and understandable….CONGRATULATIONS for your imagery and creativity, Hayim.
    And applicable in software Design this is genialty of your brain…..Wish you to be always blessed and brainy! Hag sameah

  2. Kenneth Katz says:

    All good points. Chag samach!

  3. vainolo says:

    Great Post! Thanks

  4. Avri says:

    You need to be careful not to “underdo” your thinking otherwise you will end up with a lemon, which looks like a Etrog Mehoudar but will not do as one of the 4 Sukkoth species.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s